Cambridge May 11th 1746
Couzang,
I received yr. letter very unexpected but very gladly; but being Sabbath day after meeting att night & almost prayer time I must be very breif which pray excuse. As for yr. Query: I have recollected all the little I know about the Scriptures but cant find the place that directly informs that Christ died only for the Elect; for if he died only for the Elect how can every one be welcome to come to him. Tho' I cant give a text in Scripture to prove it I am ready to think Christ died for us all; for I've often heard so from the Pulpit. If Christ died not for us it is in vain to seek to him for pardoning mercy. If we have not merit in his Blood we cant be sav'd; & how the Birth of a Saviour will be of Great Joy to those that will be Condemned I cant as yet see: but I do think you took a Subject too high for me for I am at a loss what to think about it. I belive It has been a subject that has puzled many a Divine. If what I have said be not according to Scripture I should take It very kind to be put into a right way of thinking. In disputing from Points of so great importance we are very apt to get into wrong notions and if it were a Pint of less Concearn it would Do as well. I intend to pay you a visit in a short time and then will settle matter with you but must now remain yr. sincere freind & willing Couzang,
ROBERT TREAT PAINE
PS Please to keep my lines as private as you may Depend upon it I keep yours.