Papers of John Adams, volume 21
N. 6.
Since the date of my last Letter, (December 21. 1794.) a revolution has taken place, the substance of which had been for some time expected, but the forms of which have been infinitely milder, than had ever entered the imagination of any man. The french Army of the North, after a brillant and successful campaign from March till December, had at length reached the banks of the Waal, and was for several weeks arrested in its progress, by the natural barriers which at all times have constituted the most important defence of these Provinces. Just at that period a succession of weather almost without example both in point of severity and of duration, fastened all the waters of the Country, and while it constructed a safe and easy passage for the French Republicans, into the Heart of Holland, it rendered the resource of inundations impracticable to their enemies
The existing Government of this Union, was not prepared for an Event like this. The troops of the Republic capable of opposing the march of the enemy, were already reduced by the events of the war from 50,000 to less than 15000 men. Of their allies, the Austrians gave them but little assistance, the Prussians, none at all, and the British were considered as a burthen rather than a defence.
The prevalence of British Councils, was however
unimpaired in the cabinet. It had been proposed as early as October, to send
Commissioners to Paris, to negociate a Peace. A consent to receive them had
already then been obtained, but the compliance of the British Government
with the measure, was thought indispensable,
and could not be obtained.
It is presumed however that it was finally granted, as the measure was taken. Two Commissioners were dispatched to Paris, but their authority was not commensurate with the exigency of affairs. The speech of the King of Great Britain at the opening of his Parliament seems to disapprove the steps but his Ambassador here still continued his Legislative functions, and two commissioners of the french Republic, who in consequence of his instructions had been kept in confinement since last May, were not liberated from Prison, even after the departure of the deputies upon their pacific mission.1
The Armistice which was the primary object of their negotiation, 373 could not be obtained. The Waal and
the Rhine became passable upon the Ice, and the passage of the former was
accordingly effected by the French. On the 8th:
of January a council of War was held at Utrecht consisting of the Austrian,
Hanoverian, British & Dutch Generals and the British Ambassador:2 The result of it was one
more effort of resistance on the part of the Allies. The actions of the 9th: and 10th: were
severe; but their issue only served to prove the insufficiency of the allied
forces for the defence of this Country. From that period, they gave up the
point and have since then been employed in executing their retreat into
Germany. The Province of Utrecht capitulated, and the french troops entered
the City on the 17th:
The next day, the Stadholder and his family left the Hague, and embarked in fishing boats at Schevaning for England. He had previously demanded and obtained of the States General, the dismission of his two sons as Generals in the service of the Republic.3 He then requested, and received from the States-General, and from the States of Holland, leave of absence for an indefinite time, and declared his intention to return and resume the functions of his offices whenever circumstances may permit, and testified his regret that he had not been able hitherto to serve the Republic more effectually.
The plan of operations, at Amsterdam, the execution of which had no doubt been previously concerted, so as to avoid the appearance of a conquest, commenced on the day of the Stadholder’s departure from the Hague.
A Dutch officer appeared with an order from the General
of the Batavian Corps in the french service, to
the Commander of the Garrison then in that
City, directing him and his Garrison to lay down their arms, and he
exhibited to the Regency, a Commission
constituting him, Commandant of the place. The former Garrison consisted
altogether of troops, who had already been made prisoners of War by the
french upon the frontiers, and had stipulated not to serve against them
during this War. The Regency sensible that any further resistance to defend
their authority could end only in their total destruction, directed the then
Commander to surrender according to the summons, and received the Batavian
from the french Army as Commandant of the City.
About thirty french hussars were then introduced within
the Walls, who took their station, before the Stadhouse, on the morning of
the 19th: the three coloured flag, was hoisted
on that building; the tree of liberty was erected before it; And an immense
crowd of people had collected together about it.— A revolutionary Committee, 374
consisting of ten persons, self-constituted, or at least whose origin is
traced no further, after appeared in
front of the house; one of their Members read to the crowd people there assembled, a list of
twenty-one names, of persons appointed
nominated by the revolutionary Committee, to constitute the Assembly of
Provisional Representatives of the People of Holland Amsterdam. He then demanded of the people, whether they
approved the nomination, and was answered by a general shout of
acquiescence.
From that moment the provisional Representatives, deemed themselves vested, with the whole power of the Sovereign People of Amsterdam. And they commenced their functions by sending word to the former Regency, that the people had no further occasion for their services.
Since that time they have distributed their accumulated
powers into a variety of Committees, for instance, of Public Safety, of General Vigilance, of Justice, of Finance, and of trade
and Navigation; besides constituting a Mayor to superintend the
police of the City.
In all the other Cities of the Province a similar revolution was effected in the course of a few days. In all, the ancient Regencies either did in fact, or by a revolutionary fiction were supposed to have surrendered their authority into the hands of the People. A list of new names, was always ready to be presented for acceptance, in order to substitute a provisional authority correspondent to that which was annihilated, and where the approbation of the audience, was not testified by acclamations, their silence was taken for consent.
While this operation was going through, the admission of the french troops was also taking place.
The internal Revolution at Amsterdam, you will observe
was effected on the 19th: of the month. The next
day the General of the Army, and the Commissaries of the National
Convention, arrived and were received as friends. The latter immediately published a Proclamation to the
Batavian People.
4 They declared that they came as
friends and allies. That they would respect the persons the property and the
opinions of every individual. That the independence of the Batavian People
should not be violated. That in the exercise of its Sovereignty, that People
alone should reform or modify the Government, and that all excesses between the Inhabitants should be
prevented.
In this manner was a total revolution of the Sovereignty
within, and the introduction of a foreign army of seventy thousand men,
effected in this Province, within the course of a week, and without 375
the shedding of a drop of blood,
without violence, and almost without tumult. the crisis of transition lasted
but a day, and was attended only with noise. Since then, the usual
tranquility has been uninterrupted; every thing about us has the same
appearance that it had before. Excepting that instead of Orange flags, and
cockades, and pictures, are substituted french soldiers, the three-coloured
ribband, and the tree of liberty.
But although the Sovereign of the ancient Constitution
was no more, its Deputations constituting the States of Holland, and all
their Derivatives, yet existed. The revolution was hitherto confined to the
municipal, establishments, and it became
necessary to extend it to the Provincial
government. The fundamental principle of the new system was pursued, as
closely as could be without great inconvenience. The new municipal regencies
in the several cities, deputed from each of their own bodies three or four
persons to meet together and administer the Government of the Province.
These deputies from ten or twelve Cities (for the revolution was not then
completed in all) assembled at the Hague on the 26th: of January. They took possession of the Hall, where the States
of Holland had always held their Session, having first sent word to the
Pensionary Van de Spiegel, and to all the former members of the equestrian
order, that none of them would be admitted to
their deliberations. They chose Peter Paulus of Rotterdam President for a
fortnight; assumed the title of the Assembly of
provisional Representatives of the People of Holland, and made an
express acknowledgment of the Sovereignty of the People, and the rights of
Men and Citizens. They also declared that as an immediate consequence from
these principles, The States of Holland and West-Friesland, consisting of an
Equestrian order and voting Cities, as also all hereditary offices of
Stadholder, Captain and Admiral General were annulled, and they determined
that the votes in their Assembly should be personal and not by Cities. They
abolished also the Gecommitteerde-Raad, and divided their functions between
three Committees of their own body. They recalled all the members of the
Province in the Colleges of the Generality, and appointed three of their
members, to take the Seat of the Province in the States-General, and hold it
as long as the present confederation shall continue.
The example of this Province, has been imitated in those of Utrecht, Guelders and Over-Yssel. Zeeland has capitulated, and as soon as the passage is opened for the french troops the new system, will in all probability be adopted there.
376The troops of their friends are quartered upon the inhabitants of the Cities. The discipline of the army is rigorous, and well observed. The only complaint I have heard against it is its being too severe. The examples of capital punishments which have been inflicted in more than one of the cities upon soldiers guilty of the most trifling thefts, are painful to a people among whom the penalty of Death is very seldom executed, and reserved for the most enormous crimes.
The Pensionary Van de Spiegel, the Grand-Baillif of the Hague, Bentinck, the deputy Greffier of the States-General, Lelyveld, two brothers of the Greffier Fagel, and three members of the Regency of Leyden, are under arrest.5 All the members of the Regencies dismissed, are forbidden upon the severest penalties, to go out of the Province: Some of them are held to be responsible for considerable deficiencies in the public Treasury’s, and others are supposed to be liable to criminal prosecutions.
When the revolution shall have pervaded the seven Provinces, it is expected that a Convention will be chosen to form a new Constitution. The Sovereignty of the People, the equality of individuals, universal suffrage, a single Assembly and Committees, will form the basis of the future Government.6
The Communication with foreign Countries is suspended, and that with France is not yet fully restored. We are therefore in a great measure deprived of external intelligence.
The direct Commerce with the United States, will I hope be soon revived and receive greater encouragements than it has ever yet had. Whatever the motives of the former Government might be, it is certain that their regulations were very unfavourable to the Navigation of our Country. The friendly dispositions of those who have now succeeded are the more unequivocal, because they rest upon the foundation of their interest, and even of their necessities.
Among the members of the present Administrations are many
of your former friends. The President of the provincial Assembly, Mr: Paulus, particularly requested me to present
you the testimony of his remembrance. Even the cautious aversion of Mr: William Willink, to public employment has
been obliged to yield to the exigency of the times. He is upon the Committee
of Finance at Amsterdam, and reluctantly submitted to the established
regulation, which permits no man to decline the task of public service
assigned to him.
The Apartments of the Princess of Orange, are occupied by
the Commissaries of the National Convention, who are styled the
Representatives of the french People. They received the visit from the 377 Minister of the United States at
Amsterdam, where he happened to be at the time of their arrival. They
assured him that they considered it altogether as a fraternal visit, and
expressed themselves in terms of the utmost civility, towards the United
States, their President and Vice-President. They appear to be well pleased
with Mr: Monroe; but as to his Predecessor . . .
they spoke of him too, more than once.7
The General in chief of the Northern Army Pichegru, is lodged in the building, called the old Court. In the course of three years he has risen from the rank of a Serjeant of Artillery, to that in which he now appears, and in which he has performed a campaign unparalleled in the History of Europe. He avoids as much as possible every appearance of public display; his dispatches to the Convention are remarkable for the modest simplicity with which he relates the most important successes, and he appears to prefer conversing upon any subject rather than that connected with his own exploits.
This disposition may be in some degree the result of a natural temper; but it may be partly attributed to a system, taught by the fatal experience of so many preceding Generals.
It is impossible to foresee what effect the Events herein
related, will produce upon the system of Europe. The king of Prussia has a
Minister at Paris.8 The
Imperial Diet has determined upon a negotiation for Peace. The People of
England begin to be impatient for the same object. Spain is reduced to the
last extremity, and all Europe is exhausted and tired of the desolating War
in which it has been so long involved. But the perseverance of the British
Ministry, concurring with the inveteracy of the french nation, will produce
one Campaign more; and it is yet uncertain whether this Republic will be
permitted to remain in future neutral, or whether it is only taken from one
side of the scales, to be thrown into the other: If she ceases to be a
belligerant power, her present situation will open a very advantageous
commerce to American enterprize. If she only changes sides in the war, an
equally promising source of speculation will be opened, but will then depend
partly upon the Justice of another maritime power. The treaty signed on the
19th: of November last, must before this
have been the subject of discussion and of decision in America. Whether
ratified or not many important points and sources of difference will remain
undecided. At present it is more than ever the interest of the island to
avoid a serious misunderstanding with the United States; they on their part
stand upon advantageous ground, to resent any violation of their neutral
rights. 378 The present state of affairs, will
make their reclamations for entire Justice, compatible with Prudence, and if
it should be denied, the means of increasing their federative strength, will
perhaps be in their hands.
I am, my Dear Sir, in all possible duty and affection, your Son
RC (Adams Papers); internal address: “The Vice-President.”; endorsed by JA: “N. 6. / J. Q. Adams / Hague Feb. 12. 1795”; and by AA: “JQA Febry 12 1795.” LbC (Adams Papers); APM Reel 128. Tr (Adams Papers).
In his 21 Dec. 1794 letter, JQA
struggled to separate truth from rumor regarding war news in Europe and
commented on residual British influence in Dutch politics (JQA, Writings
, 1:254–255). For the French invasion of the
Netherlands and the stadholder’s flight to England, see JQA’s 23 Oct.
letter, and note 4, above.
Locked in an increasingly costly and wide-ranging
global conflict with France since 1793, Great Britain was in a
precarious position, with every ally save Austria slipping away to sign
a separate peace with France by 1796. Little progress was made during
the Anglo-French peace talks of 1795. The French and other coalition
forces met with Alleyne Fitzherbert, the British ambassador at The
Hague, who served from 25 March 1794 and returned to England after the
French invasion (
AFC
, 10:415).
The princes of Orange-Nassau, William VI (1772–1843)
and William George Frederick (1774–1799), joined their father in London
exile (George Fisher, A Companion and Key to the
History of England . . . With an Appendix, London, 1832, p.
405–406).
For the capitulation of Amsterdam to French forces,
see JQA’s 23 Oct.
letter, and note 4, above. In their 20 Jan. 1795 proclamation,
French officials pledged to respect Batavian independence and bolstered
revolutionary propaganda, claiming the invasion brought liberation
(Raymond Kubben, Regeneration and Hegemony:
Franco-Batavian Relations in the Revolutionary Era, 1795–1803,
Leyden, 2011, p. 404).
These men were jailed for their political views.
Laurens Pieter van de Spiegel (1737–1800) had served as the grand
pensionary of Holland since 1787. Berend Hendrik Bentinck (1753–1830)
was a former Dutch Army commander, and Bernard Pieter van Lelyveld
(1750–1824) took over Hendrik Fagel’s post as secretary of the States
General. Fagel’s brothers Jacob (1766–1835) and Robbert (1771–1856),
both diplomats, were also imprisoned. Peter Paulus (1754–1796) was a
Dutch merchant who previously solicited JA’s aid in
immigrating to the United States (vol. 12:443,
445; Biografisch Portaal van Nederland; JA, D&A
, 3:5; JQA, Writings
, 1:274).
For official plans to organize the Batavian Republic’s government, see JQA’s 27 June 1795 letter, and note 9, below.
Ellipsis in MS.
Karl Augustus, Baron von Hardenberg (1750–1822),
successfully negotiated the Peace of Basel in 1795, thereby extricating
Prussia from war with France (Louis Adolphe Thiers, The History of the French Revolution,
transl. Frederick Shoberl, rev. edn., 5 vols., London, 1881, 4:183).
I had yesterday the Pleasure of receiving your kind Letter of the Sixth, and am Sorry to find that your health is so indifferent that the cold Season has so much confined you.
I am very ambitious of the honour of curing you and in order to 379 gain your Confidence, I will, like other Empiricks, tell you one of my remarkable Cures, already performed.
Some years ago, I made a Visit at New York to Sir John
Temple, whom I found upon his Couch, in a State of total Dejection and
Despondency. “He was very ill”— “He was past recovery.” “He should never go
out any more.” “He was afraid to die”—“but die he must.”— In this Strain he
ran on for Sometime, without one Word from me. At length however I ventured
to put in a Word— If you are determined to die, Sir John, there is no more
to be said— It is easy to find means—Nay I tell you, you are now in a fair
Way—persevere and you will infallibly die and that very soon. Why what would
you have me do? If you will let me quack for you and will punctually follow
my Prescriptions I will warrant you life and health and Spirits for many
Years. Pray tell me what you mean? Take your hat and Cane, every day at
twelve o Clock and walk moderately, five miles—then return to dinner and
towards Evening take your horse and ride five or ten miles more. Where did
you get that notion? from Dr Cheyne in my
Youth.—1
I took my Leave and thought no more of my Patient for Six or nine Months, after which I met Sir John on Horseback in the Street, who stoped and accosted me “sir you know not what obligations I am under to you. I owe my Life to you—I should certainly have died if you had not made me that Visit— I took your Advice and am now as well as ever I was in my Life.[”]
As I had rather save the Life of Mr Fingall2 than
that of twenty British Knights, I most earnestly recommend the same Regimen
to you, and I will forfeit all my Reputation as a Physician, if it has not
the same Success.
Before I rec’d your Letter Mr
Mitchell, who seems to be your Sincere friend, who thinks you the greatest
Genius Connecticutt ever produced, and what is better still an honest and
Usefull Man, mentioned to me with great regret that you had given in your
Resignation as Attorney General for the County. He says the Court have not
accepted it, and hopes they will not but that you will, find yourself better
and resume it. He desires me to write you his earnest request as well as
mine that you would.3 I most
heartily join him in this Prayer.
Inclosed is one more Letter to Mr Jay which I pray you to file with the others I sent you in my
last.4 The Plan and
Resolution of refusing to treat till a Commission should arrive to treat
with the 380 Minister of U.S. was mine long before
Mr Jay was associated with me in the
Commission for Peace: I suggested it to him and he heartily and ably joined
me and Franklin could do nothing without Us.
You have raised up in Connecticutt a Group of Men of Wit and Humour and Poetry, such as America never saw before and will not again see in a Century. Swift is as wicked a Wit as any of you— And you have a Clump of Tall Trees here, overtopped by no state in the Union.
We are waiting with Impatience for my Friend Jays Treaty with Britain—May it Secure Us Peace.
you see I have not forgotten all my Poetry, tho I never could make any.
I am, my dear sir as usual / your humble sert
RC (private owner, 2007); internal
address: “Mr Trumbull”; endorsed: “John
Adams VPt / Feby. 13. 1795.”
For JA’s June 1789 visit with Sir John Temple, see vol. 20:18. JA sometimes followed the regimen of British physician George Cheyne (1671–1743), a prolific medical writer (vol. 1:51).
That is, Trumbull, author of M’Fingal: A Modern Epic Poem . . . or the Town Meeting,
Phila., 1775, Evans,
No. 14528.
Stephen Mix Mitchell (1743–1835), of Wethersfield,
Conn., Yale 1763, represented Connecticut in the Senate from 1793 to
1795 (
Biog. Dir. Cong.
).
JA enclosed a copy of John Jay’s 1 Sept. 1782 letter regarding the need for British recognition of American independence prior to peace talks (vol. 13:412–413).
Alexander Pope, “The First Satire of the Second Book of Horace,” lines 75–76.