Papers of John Adams, volume 20

From John Adams to William Cranch, 14 March 1790 Adams, John Cranch, William
To William Cranch
Dear Sir New York March 14. 1790

Your favours of Decr 15. Jan. 24. and Feb. 17 are before me, and I thank for your Attention, and hope for a continuance of it, though I am not a punctual Correspondent to You.1

To the original of the Bar Meetings I was a Witness, as I was also to their excellent Effects in the Progress of them. They introduced a Candor and Liberal[ity] in the Practice at the Bar that were never before known in the Massachusetts. Mr Gardners Master Mr Pratt was so sensible of their Utility that when We took leave of him at Dedham his last Words to Us were “Bretheren, forsake not the assembling of yourselves together.2

My Advice to you, and all the young Gentlemen coming Up, as well as to those, now on the stage is never to Suffer Such Meetings to go into disuse, let who will clamour about them: for as I know the Body of the Law will never consent to any illegal or dishonourable Combinations, so on the other hand their deliberations together, on what is for the honour and dignity of the Bar and for the Public Good as 276 far as their Practice is connected with it cannot but produce benign Effects.

What? is it unlawful for the Gentlemen of the Profession to Spend an Evening together once a Week? to converse upon Law, and upon their Practice: to hear complaints of unkind unfair and ungentle-manlike Practice: to compose differences: to agree that they will not introduce ignorant, illitterate, or illbred or unprincipled Students or Candidates? that they will not practice any kind of Chicanery, or take unmanly Advantages of one another, to the Injury of Clients for accidental or inadvertent Slips in pleading or otherwise? on what unhappy times are We fallen, if that Profession without which the Laws can never be maintained nor Liberty exist, is to be treated in this tyrannical manner?

But I must Stop.— ask my son if he has received two Letters from me.3 I am / with much Esteem and affection yours

John Adams

RC (MHi:Cranch Family Papers); addressed by CA: “Mr: William Cranch. / at Judge Dawes’s / Boston.”; internal address: “Mr William Cranch.”; endorsed: “V. President March 14 1790”; notation by JA: “Free / John Adams.” LbC (Adams Papers); APM Reel 115. Text lost where the seal was removed has been supplied from the LbC.

1.

Cranch’s letters of 15 Dec. 1789 and 17 Feb. 1790 have not been found, but that of 24 Jan. is above.

2.

At the age of fourteen, John Gardiner entered the office of Benjamin Prat (1711–1763), Harvard 1737, a leading Boston lawyer whom JA admired for his “strong, elastic Spring, or what we call Smartness, and Strength in his Mind.” The allusion is to Hebrews, 10:25 ( Sibley’s Harvard Graduates , 10:226, 229, 238; 13:593, 602; JA, D&A , 1:83).

3.

For JA’s 9 and 19 Feb. letters to JQA about his son’s career prospects, see AFC , 9:14, 16.

From John Adams to Stephen Higginson, 14 March 1790 Adams, John Higginson, Stephen
To Stephen Higginson
Sir New York March 14 1790.

I am much obliged by your favor of the first instant with the report of the Committee: and glad to find that the bench has been filled with Characters to your satisfaction. The report of the Committee gives me concern, as it evidence of an unquiet restless spirit as it tends to encourage Rhode Island in their obstinacy: but most of all as I fear there is too much probability that it originated in the advice you mention, and is aided by some of the great folks you allude to— It is supposed to have been sett on foot in the Massachusetts to assist in raising the same spirit in Virginia, where there is at present a very general satisfaction with the national Government: though it is apprehended that this measure may revive some old uneasiness. I really 277 fear that some of my old friends both in Virginia and Massachusetts hold not in horror as much as I do, a division of this Continent into two or three nations and have not an equal dread of Civil war. The appearance of reviving courage in this Country is very pleasing to a man as much mortified as I have been with reproaches against the Religion, morals, honor and spirit of this Country, it is rapture to see a returning disposition to respect treaties to pay debts, and to do justice by holding property sacred and obeying the Commandment “Thou shalt not steal.” The worthy Clergymen throughout the United States when they pray for the Vice President petition that he may be endowed with the Spirit of his station in this petition I most devoutly join. And the most difficult part of the spirit of his station is to abstain from meddling improperly with the executive power. For this reason you must not depend upon any activity on my part to promote your views. This I can say however, that I beleive your qualifications for the office you mentioned to be of the best kind and equal to those of any man; that I shall make no opposition to you personally; and that whenever it may fall in my way, consistent with the aforesaid spirit of my station, to assist your wishes, it will give me pleasure to do it. I received sometime ago a letter from you, for which I was much obliged to you tho’ I fear I have never answered it.—1 The inspection of Merchandizes to be exported is one of the most important things this Country has to do. Next to the faith of treaties and the payment of debt, punctuality in the quality of merchandizes to be exported is the thing most wanted I will not say to support, but to restore the moral character of our Country. Pensylvania has derived such advantages from her inspection laws, that I wonder the Massachusetts should want any motive to follow her example.2 Some of the States derive such advantages from their own inspection laws and from the want of them in New England that opposition to a general law may arise from that interest. The national debt I have long thought, must be the instrument for establishing a national government; and have the pleasure now to see that the President, his ministers and a majority in the house are of the same opinion. I have also the satisfaction to see that the ennemies and opposers of the Government are all of the same mind. The latter are accordingly exerting themselves against the assumption of the State debts, as the pivot upon which the general government will turn. The opposition however seems to be feeble, as not supported by the voice of the people This is a favorable symptom. Indeed the government appears to have had as happy an effect upon the prosperity and peace 278 of the Country as its friends had reason to expect. it might not be too strong an expression to say that the most sanguine prophecies of its blessings and utility have been fulfilled. There are defects still in the Constitution, which if they are not supplied by degrees as it gains strength will produce evils of a serious kind.

John Adams

LbC in CA’s hand (Adams Papers); internal address: “Honble Stephen Higginson”; APM Reel 115.

1.

JA referred to Higginson’s letter of 21 Dec. 1789, above.

2.

Prior to the implementation of the Constitution, Pennsylvania merchants operated under detailed inspection laws for lucrative exports like timber, meat, flour, bread, spirits, and tobacco (Albert Anthony Giesecke, American Commercial Legislation before 1789, N.Y., 1910, p. 75–78).