Papers of John Adams, volume 20

To John Adams from James Lovell, 19 December 1789 Lovell, James Adams, John
From James Lovell
Sir Boston Decr 19th. 1789.

Though I know your extreme Delicacy as to any Interference in the executive Affairs of the U.Ss. yet to you I must apply; for, Heaven & Secretary Jackson know I may be chagrined in an Attempt to address the President.

I am in Dread least an Action should take Place which will renew the Vigour of the Opponents & damp the Spirit of the Friends of Government: And, it will be out of Time to await the Motions of a deliberate Legislature

The enclosed Copy of a Letter will explain my Dread.1 If it appears well-founded and of sufficient Importance to call for a speedy Remedy, a very mild but efficacious one may be suggested. The President may see the circular Instruction of Octr 31st. and advise that it be immediately followed by another stating the Point “to appear, upon Review, to be of such a Kind as to need, perhaps, Legislative Attention”; and therefore proposing to the Collectors to stay all Proceedings therein “till they hear again from the Treasury.[”]

I am totally rong in my Conceptions of the Business, or else it may be expected that one single Suit commenced in each of the States would produce a Multitude of News paper Suggestions of a very unpleasant Sort both respecting the General Government and its new Law Courts.

Am I consummately impudent in this Application? Whatever may be your Judgement of it, you may be assured I will attribute so much of that Charge to myself as to keep my Doings herein a profound Secret.

I am endeavouring to break the Neck of some Enemies to the french Consulate here. You must know I admire that Institution, because by the Kings Ordonnances it’s Chancery has all the Spirit & Essence of our Jury of Equals.

The Herald inclosed proclaims my first Onset, as the Printer of it 191 did not feel my sly Knock at his Licentiousness so sensibly as to refuse me the Use of his Types.2

Here, I am aground: For, as your Lady has all my Regards, what have I left for You? The Jus Mariti3 must relieve me. Demand your Quantum from the Bone of your Bone or as RTP Esquire would quaintly gallicize it—from that Bonne of You Bon.

James Lovell

RC and enclosure (Adams Papers); internal address: “His Excellency / John Adams”; endorsed: “Mr Lovel 19. Decr. / 1789.”

1.

Lovell enclosed a copy of his 17 Dec. letter to Benjamin Lincoln, expressing reluctance to comply with the collector’s 16 Dec. request for a record of Boston imports from 1 to 10 August. Once the Tariff Act took effect on 1 Aug., importers were required to pay certain customs, but they were allowed a grace period until local collecting houses were established; in Boston, they were formally created on 10 August. Lovell argued that an interim collection was unfair to importers who had sold their goods and that it targeted ports with better records. Responding to critics, Alexander Hamilton sent a circular letter on 31 Oct. to the nation’s port collectors stipulating that while customs must be collected to fund the debt, moderation was key. The backlash continued, and on 30 Dec. Hamilton again issued a circular letter. There, the treasury secretary admitted that the new policy was problematic, and he recommended that Congress revise the plan in its second session (Hamilton, Papers , 5:478–479; 6:39, 290).

2.

Despite his lack of an appointment, Lovell continued to monitor the politics of the port. When Philippe André Joseph de Létombe, the French consul at Boston, was suspected of forcing a French intendant to sign for supplies that may not have been delivered, Lovell intervened in the press. He trained his criticism on Létombe’s accuser, Louis Baury de Bellerive. Originally from St. Domingue, Bellerive (1754–1807) was a French officer who fought in the Continental Army and aided in the suppression of Shays’ Rebellion. Claiming that the charge was “false in the groundwork,” Lovell issued a four-letter defense of Létombe, which began appearing in Edmund Freeman’s Herald of Freedom the day before Lovell wrote this letter to JA. Bellerive fired back via the same newspaper, replying that Lovell had “too much of my contempt to merit further notice” (vol. 14:159; Boston Herald of Freedom, 18, 22, 25 Dec. 1789, 5 Jan. 1790; Reports of Committees of the House of Representatives Made during the First Session of the Thirty-second Congress, Washington, D.C., 1852, 147:1; AFC , 9:173). On the mounting significance of fraud in New England ports, see Stephen Higginson’s letter of 21 Dec. 1789, and note 1, below.

3.

The legal right of a husband to acquire his wife’s estate by virtue of marriage (Black, Law Dictionary ).

To John Adams from Henry Marchant, 19 December 1789 Marchant, Henry Adams, John
From Henry Marchant
Newport State of Rhode Island &c Decr. 19th. 1789 Dear Sir,

Yours of the 17th. of Sepr. I have been honored with.— I truly esteem myself so by every Mark of Your Attention— Your unexpected Visit to Boston prevented an Answer sooner— My Concern as a Friend to my Country is awakened at the Account You give of some disagreable Symptoms attending Your Breast upon close attention, 192 and in publick speaking. How we can spare You from the first I scarce can tell.— But you must somewhat abate in the Severity of it— As to the latter, Reading &c, I would advise that You let one of the Clerks do all the publick Reading, even every Motion made— I know many Explanations and Observations, Opinions &c &c must be expected from the Chair; but you have a peculiar Faculty of speaking multum in parvo—

I was very glad to find upon my Return that my Family had found out your Son:— He had taken up Lodgings and could not be tempted to release them. His very agreable Manners and Improvements rendered Him too entertaining to cause any Regret, but that of His too suddenly leaving the Town— We hope Mr. Adams and His, will never pass Us without Notice—1

You must be right, and I stand corrected as to the Time of the Prediction &c I heretofore alluded to— It must have been,—I well remember it was at Philadelphia— The Matter, and the Effect of it, as it struck my Mind, and to all Appearance every Member present I never can forget.— I have mentioned it a hundred Times, tho’ not the Author, save to a very few—

You may remember when I had the Honor of seeing you at New-York last Sept.— I informed You, Our Assembly had been called specially, after I left Newport.— That it boded no good;—and I was confident the Govr. had been induced to it, by His Friends who were alarmed at what might take Place in the New House at Octr. sessions,— And therefore were determined by some Means or other, if possible to raise some Difficulty in Their Way:— It turned out so:— The special Assembly, (at which I arrived in Time to be mortified with Their Conduct)—directed Town-Meetings to be called to give their new Members Instructions— Those New members had been appointed in Consequence of the Alteration which had greatly taken Place in the Minds of the People as to the Paper Mony System: But the People still not so much relenting in Their Opposition to the New Constitution did indeed instruct Their Members agt. a Convention— Upon Consultation out of the House, we found most of the new members would have risked giving a Vote for a Convention, if the Disposition of the People had been any way flattering, of Success in a Convention— This not being the Case, it was thought prudent, the members should conduct agreably to Their Instructions, thereby to continue Their Credit with Their Constituents, till They might be induced to more favourable Sentiments of the New Constitution— With this Opinion the old Fœderal Members politically 193 coincided Our Assembly again sits the second Monday of January— The Ground is considerably changed since the Instructions given last October. The Amendments have been sent forth by Congress, And North Carolina by a very large Majority have acceeded to the Union, And for which I sincerely give You Joy.

What effect those Circumstances may have we cannot possitively conclude. We have been often deceived in Our Hopes, and I do not wish to be sanguine— As to interested Motives, I know of none of much Importance, that we can advance to Our Country Members that have not been already urged, that will operate till the next Fall upon Them—While Our merchantile Interest on the fifteenth of January will be in a most deplorable State— It has been an unhappy Circumstance hitherto, that nothing could be done by which the merchantile and Country Interest should be affected at the same Time,—And unless the merchantile Interest is indulged till next Fall, They must suffer and severely too, at least nine Months before the Country Interest can be much affected— This however upon the Supposition that there should not be a voluntary giving up of former Sentiments, or the Measures of Congress should not prove sufficient Inducements to lead Our People to a Spirit of Condescention—

I was at New Haven the begining of Novr. where I placed my Son under President Stiles, in the second Year.—2 I arrived there two Hours after His Excellency The President, had left the Town on His Return to New-York—3

I hope You have refreshed Your Body and Spirits by Your Journey; and that you found Mrs. Adams & Family well— Be pleased to present my Respects & Compliments—

I am most truly / Your old and / sincere Friend

Hy: Marchant

RC (Adams Papers); internal address: “His Excellency John Adams Esqr.”; endorsed: “Marchant. 19. Decr / 1790 / answered March 20.”

1.

Passing through Newport, R.I., on 10 Sept. and again on 6 Oct., JQA briefly recorded meeting Marchant and his wife, Rebecca Cooke, on 11 Sept. ( AFC , 8:417, 445; D/JQA/14, APM Reel 17).

2.

William Marchant (1774–1857), of Newport, Yale 1792, later served as chief justice of the Court of Common Pleas in Rhode Island (Dexter, Yale Graduates , 5:30).

3.

As part of his New England tour, George Washington visited New Haven from 17 to 19 Oct. and met Gov. Samuel Huntington, Lt. Gov. Oliver Wolcott Sr., and Mayor Roger Sherman. The president heard two addresses, one by state lawmakers and another by Congregationalist clergy, and replied with thanks for the “tender interest which you have taken in my personal happiness, and the obliging manner in which you express yourselves on the restoration of my health.” After a trip to Yale College, Washington learned about the area’s linen manufacturers and glassworks (Washington, Diaries , 5:463–466, 467; Connecticut Journal, 21 Oct.).