Papers of John Adams, volume 19

To John Adams from Philip Mazzei, 24 February 1787 Mazzei, Philip Adams, John
From Philip Mazzei
Most esteemed & dear Sir, Paris, 24. Feby: 1787.

I took the liberty to trouble you with a letter by Col. Franks, in which I desired the favor of you to inform me abt. a law of Massachussets, which (according to Mr. Jefferson’s memory) Dr. Franklin told him it was enacted in the beginning of this Century, & tended to discourage the introduction of emigrants.1 I would be glad to Know the epoc, as near as possible, if not exactly; whether the same law was adopted by any other of the New-England Colonies, & at what time; the real motive & the intent of it, &c. &c. Dear Sir, you must submit with patiance to the trouble I give you; it is not my fault, if you are the only fountain I can apply to, to satisfy my thirst.

Your law abt. slavery, I am told, gives freedom to every one who claims it. This law is likewise one of those I would be glad to Know the same particulars of, as above. Some say it is an old law, & others pretend that it was made since the Revolution.

We are about preventing your book falling into bad hands. Many people will would grasp at it for the sake of gain, & probably would soon publish an indifferent, or bad translation of it. We want to have 24 it done by an able hand, & hope to succeed. At least my endeavours shall not be wanting; & I think myself interested in it as a Citizen of America, exclusive of my regard & esteem for the Author.

I have not had it in my power, yet to peruse any part of your book; Mr. Jefferson having not quite done with his copy, the Marquis having taken his with him to Versailles, & Count of Sarcefield being just come to Town. I dont Know that there is any more copies of it in Paris, & wish there was no more, to avoid the danger of a bad translator being before hand with us. I have (by chance only) happined to observe a mistake, relative to the Nobility in the System of Locke. There was no Barons, & the share of acres for a Landgrave was 48,000, instead of 80,000.

Art. III. The whole province shall be divided into Counties; each County shall consist of eight Signories, eight baronies, and four precincts; each precinct shall consist of six colonies.2

IV. Each Signiory, Barony, and Colony shall consist of twelve thousand acres; the eight Signiories being the share of the eight Proprietors, and the eight Baronies of the nobility.—

IX. There shall be just as many Landgraves as there are Counties, and twice as many Cassiques, and no more. These shall be the hereditary nobility of the province, and by right of their dignity be members of parliament. Each Landgrave shall have four Baronies, and each Cassique two Baronies, hereditarily and unalterably annexed to, and settled upon, the said dignity.

Be so good as to let me Know, if you chuse that the mistake should be corrected in the translation; & in case I should discover any other, whether you allow me to inform you of my observations, in hope that you will instruct me what to do.

I will be much obliged to you for an immediate answer. Be so good as to present my respectful & sincere compliments to Mrs. Adams, & Mrs. Smith; & to remember me very affectionately to Col. Smith; while I have the honor to be with the greatest regard & esteem, / Dear Sir, / your most Obedient and / most Humble Servant

Philip Mazzei

P.S. I would be glad to Know, if it is true, that Wm. Penn, the Founder of Pensilvania, died in the Fleet Prison, &, if true, to have an authentic proof of it.3

The Abbé Raynal says p. 185. vol. 9. “Des sectaires humains; des chrétiens qui cherchoient dans l’évangile plutôt des vertus que des dogmes, ont sonvent voulu rendre à leur esclaves la liberté que rien 25 ne peut remplacer: mais ils ont été long-tems retenus par une loi qui ordonnoit d’assigner aux affranchis un revenu suffisant pour leur subsistance.”4

Will you be so good, my dear Sir, as to tell me how far the Abbé is mistaken, & to afford me the means to confute him?

RC (Adams Papers); addressed: “His Excellency / John Adams Esqre:, Minister Plenipy. / from the United American States to the / Court of / London” and “Grosvenor Square”; endorsed: “Mr. Mazzei. 24. Feb. / ansd. 1. May. 1787”; notation: “fountain.”

1.

With this letter, Mazzei resumed lines of scholarly inquiry for his four-volume Recherches historiques et politiques, Paris, 1788. By Lt. Col. David S. Franks, Mazzei wrote to JA on 11 Jan. (Adams Papers), inquiring about early Massachusetts legislation that possibly obliged “the Captains of Vessels to give security for the good behaviour of emigrants brought by them,” and whether this changed modes of migration to Massachusetts and Pennsylvania. For similar examples of Mazzei’s research queries and JA’s replies, see vol. 18:xxx, 45–49, 298–299, 355–356.

2.

Here, and in the next two articles, Mazzei quoted from the “Fundamental Constitutions of Carolina,” as cited in the four-volume 1768 London edition of The Works of John Locke.

3.

William Penn (1644–1718), English Quaker and founder of Pennsylvania, was frequently incarcerated throughout his life for financial troubles and controversial political views, but he did not die in jail. After suffering a debilitating stroke in 1712, Penn died in Ruscombe, Berkshire Co., England ( ANB ).

4.

A contemporary translation reads: “On Human Sectarians; some Christians, who cleave to the scriptures rather than to the virtues of dogma, have often wanted to give their slaves that liberty for which there is no substitute, but they were prevented from it by a law that required them to assign to the freed slaves enough money to support them” (Mazzei, Writings , 1:546).

From John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 1 March 1787 Adams, John Jefferson, Thomas
To Thomas Jefferson
Dear sir London March 1. 1787 1

I am much obliged to you for your favours of Feb. 20. and 23 by Mr Carnes, and the curious Pamphlets.

Opening a direct Communication between Paris and America will facilitate the Trade of the two Countries, very much, and the new Treaty between France and England, will promote it still more. John Bull dont see it. and if he dont See a Thing at first, you know it is a rule with him ever afterwards to swear that it dont exist, even when he does both see it and feel it.

I have this moment written to Messrs Willinks and Vanstaphorsts to remit to you or Mr Grand in your Absence, what remains to be recd to make up the Thousand Guineas for the Swords and Medals. You having before drawn for 6500 Livres tournois, as part of them.2

My Resolution of Quitting Europe, has been taken upon mature deliberation: but really upon motives of Necessity, as much at least as Choice.— Congress cannot consistent with their own honour and 26 Dignity, renew my Commission to this Court—and I assure you, I should hold it so inconsistent with my own honour and Dignity little as that may be, that if it were possible for Congress to forget theirs I would not forget mine, but send their Commission back to them, unless a Minister were sent from his Britannic Majesty to Congress.

As to a Residence in Holland, that Climate is so destructive to my health, that I could never bear it: and I am Sure it would be fatal to her, on whom depends all the Satisfaction that I have in Life.— No Consideration would tempt me to think of removing to that Country with my Family.—

For a Man who has been thirty Years rolling like a stone never three years in the same Place, it is no very pleasant Speculation, to cross the seas with a Family, in a State of Uncertainty what is to be his fate; what reception he shall meet at home; whether he shall set down in private Life to his Plough; or push into turbulent scænes of Sedition and Tumult; whether be sent to Congress, or a Convention or God knows what.— If it lay in my Power, I would take a Vow, to retire to my little Turnip Yard, and never again quit it.— I feel very often a violent disposition to take some Resolution & swear to it. But upon the whole, it is best to preserve my Liberty to do as I please according to Circumstances.

The Approbation You express in general of my poor Volume, is a vast consolation to me. it is an hazardous Enterprize, and will be an unpopular Work in America for a long time.— When I am dead, it may be regretted that Such Advice was not taken in the season of it.— But as I have made it early in life and all along, a Rule to conceal nothing from the People which appeared to me material for their Happiness and Prosperity, however unpopular it might be at the time, or with particular Parties, I am determined not now to begin to flatter popular Prejudices and Party Passions however they may be countenanced, by great Authorities.

The Opinion you Object to “p. 362. that Congress is not a legislative but a diplomatic assembly” I should wish to have considered as a Problem, rather for Consideration, than as an Opinion: and as a Problem too, relative to the Confederation as it now Stands, rather than to any other Plan that may be in Contemplation of the States.— It is a most difficult Topick, and no Man at a distance can judge of it, So well as those in America. if the Book Should be translated into french, I wish you would insert this, in a Note. You have laid me under great Obligation, by taking the trouble to Secure a Good 27 Translator.— if the Thing is worth translating at all, it will not surely bare to loose any Thing by the Translation.— But will not the Government proscribe it?— if I should get well home, and Spend a few Years in Retirement, I Shall pursue this Subject, some what further: but I hope never to be left, again, to publish So hasty a Production as this.— a Work upon the Subject you mention, Nobility in general, which I once hinted to you a Wish to see handled at large would be too extensive and Splendid for my means and Forces. it would require many Books which I have not, and a more critical Knowledge both of ancient and modern Languages than at my Age a Man can aspire to.— There are but two Circumstances, which will be regretted by me, when I leave Europe. one is the opportunity of Searching any questions of this kind, in any books that may be wanted. and the other will be the Interruption of that intimate Correspondence with you, which is one of the most agreable Events in my Life. There are four or five Persons here, with whom I hold a friendly Intercourse and shall leave with Some degree of Pain but I am not at home in this Country.

With every affectionate and friendly sentiment / I am and shall be in this World and the futu[re] / yours

John Adams3

RC (DLC:Jefferson Papers); internal address: “Mr Jefferson.”; endorsed: “Adams John.” LbC (Adams Papers); APM Reel 112. Text lost due to a tight binding has been supplied from the LbC.

1.

JA last wrote to Jefferson on 20 Feb., introducing Rev. William Gordon and asking Jefferson to “recommend his History to your Patronage in France” (Jefferson, Papers , 11:170).

2.

On 28 Feb., JA wrote to the loan consortium, instructing it to furnish Jefferson with the remainder of the funds needed to pay for the special commission (LbC, APM Reel 113).

3.

JA next wrote to Jefferson on 18 April, recommending John Mortimer of Fredericksburg, Va., the only son of Dr. Charles Mortimer, who later served as physician to George Washington’s family. JA described the younger Mortimer as “a worthy, though unfortunate Man” capable of “litterary Employment as a Teacher of Languages” (Jefferson, Papers , 11:298; Washington, Papers, Presidential Series , 5:540).