Diary of Charles Francis Adams, volume 5

Sunday. 17th. CFA

1833-02-17

Sunday. 17th. CFA
Sunday. 17th.

The snow now begins to disappear. A considerable body of it has been collecting gradually. Read Montaigne for an hour. His Chapter upon human inconsistency is admirable. I have not generally seen the merit of this Author, but that Chapter contains a deep insight into human nature.

Attended divine service all day. Mr. Frothingham preached, from John 9. 2. “And his disciples asked him, saying, Master, who did sin, this man or his parents, that he was born blind.” He took upon himself to confute the idea that the Deity could be considered as punishing in the various dispensations which men in this world experienced—An idea which, he said, was familiarly cherished by the Hebrews and was even now somewhat entertained in the Christian world. With respect to the punishment of children for the faults of their fathers, I do not pretend to believe in it, although there is something in the apparent government of the Universe to cherish the idea. It would be exceedingly difficult however to convince me, that according to the laws governing man, he is not often made to pay the penance of his sin by his own suffering corporeal or mental, in this world. Even the hereditary complaints which are the consequences of vicious conduct most frequently, however they may seem to fall upon the innocent, fix no little mortification and suffering in the minds of the guilty persons. For myself, I must candidly confess that my own experience has shown me strongly the fact that I can not do wrong with impunity. Whatever intentional misconduct I may have been guilty of, has left no little of the suffering which has fallen to my share to atone for it. And on the other hand, the happiness of my life has invariably dated from the quiet performance of duty, not fully perhaps, but then not unwillingly.

Afternoon. Matthew 9. 8. “But when the multitudes saw it, they marvelled, and glorified God, which had given such power unto men.” Text relates to a miracle, the performing of which has ceased. But the Sermon related to the power conferred ordinarily by the Deity upon man and divided it into five parts, the power over the productions of the earth, that over inferior creatures, that over the elements, over events and lastly the power of men over themselves.

32

On my return home, which was somewhat delayed by a visit at Mrs. Frothingham’s, I read a Sermon of Massillon’s for the occasion of the day of commemoration of the Virgin. Subject, Fidelity as exemplified in her, to be secured by measures of precaution, and by those of correspondence as he styles it, which I take to mean merely perseverance. The dangers of Fidelity under the first division are stated to be self weakness, the opinion of the world and the forgetfulness of grace, the measures of precaution are seclusion from and indifference to the judgments of men, and gratitude to be constantly cherished; under the second division, the dangers are from not pursuing as well as straying from the path of grace, both which must be avoided by perseverance. Quiet evening at home, finished Ruffhead and read Herder.

Monday. 18th. CFA

1833-02-18

Monday. 18th. CFA
Monday. 18th.

I went to the Office this morning but had scarcely got there before I perceived I had left my keys with the child to play with. The consequence was that I could do nothing. I therefore went down to the Althenaeum to read the Newspapers and try to make up an opinion upon the speech and bill of Mr. Clay. On reflection, I think the speech is worse than the other. It is unstatesmanlike, and unsound. It gives no views that are either just or generous. It stamps the man.

I read or rather skimmed Henry Lee’s publication in answer to the Memoirs of Jefferson. It falls into the very vice it blames. It is abusive to Jefferson, my grandfather and father, and lauds Hamilton. Mr. Lee has erred extremely. He might have made a strong case against his adversary if he had only been careful to avoid that kind of crimination which shows a partisan. His hostility to my father is excessive, considering that the latter has generally thought rather favourably of him. His moral character is so bad that no little pains ought to be taken by him to avoid unnecessarily aspersing those of others.1

Walk, and dined with Gorham Brooks at the Tremont House. Mr. Brooks, Mr. and Mrs. Frothingham and Abby. His wine is good. I returned home for half an hour which was wasted, and went down again to tea and the Theatre. Masaniello again. It was well done, home late. Read the World.

1.

Major Henry Lee of Virginia, for whom JQA entertained respect as a writer and whom he had appointed early in his Administration to a minor position in the Post Office Department, had while in that office been engaged in political writing for Calhoun. Upon resigning in 1826, Lee became a pamphleteer and newspaper propagandist for Jackson. Jackson had rewarded him with an interim appointment as consul general at Algiers but when his name was pre-33sented in the Senate, confirmation was denied on grounds of his profligacy and personal morals. His Observations on the Writings of Thomas Jefferson, N.Y., 1832, was the second book in which he undertook to defend his father, “Lighthorse Harry” Lee, from what he judged to be unwarranted attacks. JQA, Memoirs , 7:180–182; 9:346–347; DAB .