Adams Family Correspondence, volume 13

Thomas Boylston Adams to William Smith Shaw, 8 September 1799 Adams, Thomas Boylston Shaw, William Smith
Thomas Boylston Adams to William Smith Shaw
Dear William. Germantown 8th: September 1799

I have your favor of the 31st: ulto: with an enclosure for R. Peters Junr: which shall be delivered as soon as an opportunity of sending it, presents— I have not yet found means to forward the last enclosure you made me—which is rather the effect of misfortune than neglect, though you doubtless will think I have no excuse for being nine weeks within 3 miles of the Bishops, without having made one single visit there.1 The fact is, I have been very little from the spot of my retreat in any direction except to Frankford, where I last week attended Court & took the oath as a practitioner therein. I hope that the money which a licence to practise costs, may be placed at good interest, but the prospect is barren—

I shall have to attend another Court next this week at Frankford, where a Cred Debtor of my brother is to avail himself of the cheating insolvent law of this State passed last year, and under which the most flagrant frauds & perjuries are practised. The debtor always gets out, unless you can convict him of perjury by discovering property which he has not disclosed. The man in question, is a swindling fellow, who borrowed money of my brother at the Hague, to prevent his going to Jail in Holland. It seems he has not been able to escape it here. His name, J P. Ripley. 2

This morning (the 10th: Septr) I got your favor of the 2d: with enclosures, for which accept my cordial thanks.3 The affray between Livermore & Lee, had fallen under my observation, but the pieces I had never seen, except Lee’s publication. Fisher Ames’s remark, that “a character, even unjustly aspersed, never appears so unsullied, as before,” occurs forcibly to my recollection on this occasion.4

One of my speculative letters to you of the latter end of July, remains, I think yet unacknowledged—I wont be sure however— The subject most descanted on was, my attempting to renew an acquaintance with School & College books— I notice this circumstance for no particular reason, though a doubt exists whether it reached you.—5 Several of my letters went to town by different private conveyances 552 and some of them might have miscarried naturally enough. At present we have a regular post Office established here during the fever.

The Aurora pronounces the letters which appeared a few days since in the papers, relative to the assassination of the frenchmen at Rastadt, a bare faced forgery.6 The story is so consonant to my own suspicions & to the appearances which struck our notice in the relation on the french side, that I think them genuine, though their coming here first from St Sebastian is against them. We shall soon know the fact.

The mortality in Philadelphia increases slowly—for many days the average was about 20. and has never exceeded 31. A long spell of rainy weather has prevailed and we hope checked the disease in a degree. Several useful men have fallen within a short time.

I have nothing of moment to say further than an assurance / of the esteem & friendship / of

T. B. A.

If you can obtain for me the words of the patriotic songs, written by Mr: Paine, I shall thank you— There are two or three.7 Quincy will ask for them of the Author, if you give him a hint with my best remembrance. Paine has a claim on me for a retribution, which on occasion I shall be happy to make. I think highly of his poetic talents, and wish he might meet as much admiration & encouragement as his genius merits. A professional poet cannot live here by his trade, & unluckily he is seldom fit for any other— I think, that when the Gods make a man poetical, it is a sure mark of their vengeance not their mercy.

RC (MWA:Adams Family Letters); addressed: “W S Shaw / Quincy”; internal address: “W S Shaw.”; endorsed: “Germantown 8th Sep / T B Adams / rec 15th / Ansd 20 / Sent 24th.”; docketed: “1799 / Sept 8.”

1.

These letters have not been found.

2.

For the origin of the debt John Phillips Ripley owed JQA, see JQA to TBA, 2 Oct. 1798, and note 6, above. Ripley published a legal notice in the Philadelphia American Daily Advertiser, 7 Sept. 1799, stating that the Penn. Supreme Court would hear his insolvency case in Frankford on 13 September. The case was apparently not resolved, as JQA still held the note from Ripley in Nov. 1801 (D/JQA/24, 13 Nov., APM Reel 27).

3.

Not found.

4.

On 17 July 1799 Judge Edward St. Loe Livermore of Portsmouth, N.H., delivered an address in which he suggested that William Lee had returned from France the previous summer with French passports obtained through a “species of bribery.” Those passports offered protection from French privateers, Livermore claimed, and were offered for sale to fellow merchants after Lee’s return. Responding in Boston newspapers, Lee charged Livermore with “a malicious and scandalous falsehood,” to which Livermore answered with a 14 Aug. letter stating that he meant no slight and cited the episode only to illustrate French corruption. After it was revealed that Lee had in fact purchased passports, Livermore published a 17 Aug. letter declaring his earlier statement proven. On 22 Aug. Lee assaulted Livermore in Portsmouth, and a physical altercation ensued between the 553 two men (Edward St. Loe Livermore, An Oration, in Commemoration of the Dissolution of the Political Union Between the United States of America and France, Portsmouth, N.H., 1799, p. 20–21, Evans, No. 35736; Boston Independent Chronicle, 8–12, 19–22 Aug.; Boston Columbian Centinel, 14, 17, 24 Aug.; Philadelphia Gazette of the United States, 2 Sept.). For more on Lee’s time in France, see AA to William Smith, 9 June 1798, and note 2, above.

5.

TBA to Shaw, 29 July 1799, above.

6.

Details surrounding the assassination of French envoys by Austrian hussars at Rastatt, Germany, on 28 April remained unclear. In early September New York newspapers published letters allegedly written by a Prussian officer present at the assassination, which shifted blame from the Prussians to the French. The Philadelphia Aurora General Advertiser, 7 Sept., called the letters an “impudent fabrication.” Later commentators considered the letters to be forgeries (New York Commercial Advertiser, 2 Sept.; New York Spectator, 4 Sept.; Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Essays on his Own Times, ed. Sara Coleridge, 3 vols., London, 1850, 1:279–280; Der Rastadter gesandtenmord, Vienna, 1874, p. 160–162; Cambridge Modern Hist. , 8:655–656).

7.

In addition to “Adams and Liberty” and “To Arms Columbia,” in 1798 and 1799, Boston printer Thomas Paine composed “Adams and Washington,” “The Green Mountain Farmer,” and “Rise Columbia!” (O. G. Sonneck, Bibliography of Early Secular American Music, Washington, D.C., 1905, p. 2–3, 62, 126, 155).

Thomas Boylston Adams to Abigail Adams, 16 September 1799 Adams, Thomas Boylston Adams, Abigail
Thomas Boylston Adams to Abigail Adams
Rock Hall. Germantown 16th. Septr [1799] My dear Mother.

On the 11th: instt: I received your favor of the 4th: and last evening, on my return from Mr: Breck’s Country seat, where I passed Friday & Saturday night’s, your’s of the 8th: had come to hand. Same time, recd: from William the poem you sent me for Miss Wister & his letter of the 6th: I am obliged by all these things & newspapers to boot. Coopers address, valedictory, I now remember to have seen & read at the time it first appeared, and upon a second perusal, I shall only say, that if Dr: Priestly could recommend such a man as Cooper to office, & assist in giving currency to such opinions as are here expressed, he deserves all, that Porcupine ever wrote or any body else could think against him— I had never heard of his meddling before in any of our political concerns—But I have been told, that “the french Republic,” is still a standing toast with him. Dennie, does not like him, as you may have observed from his remarks on the New Englandman’s letter, though he had only seen the prospectus of it when he commented.1 These exotic reputations are slipp’ry things to build on. I find so little fame, that stands the test of all trials & all scrutiny, that I am sometimes disposed to become a cynic & carp indiscriminately at all that fa[ll] in my way.

I enclose you an extract of a letter from J.Q.A. which came to hand a few days ago— The original letter I shall have to answer before it could be returned to me if I should send it. Indeed, the rest is all of 554 a private and uninteresting nature to any body but myself. I had an idea of sending this extract to the Printer, but he has neglected something I sent him a few days ago, so ungraciously that I wont subject myself to a second slight. These Philadelphia Printers are poor tools to work with on their own side. The Aurora is infinitely the best edited of any among them. This extract will better appear at this moment in a Boston paper, if it be worth appearing at all, so that you may send it to Russell in its present shape, altering only the name of [the] place where received.2 The Treaty with Prussia was signed on the 11th: July, and I suppose a copy has been received e’re this by the Secy—though I know not that it has been.3 I got a letter from Whitcomb since that from my brother, though not so late—& I expect a letter or two of an earlier date from him than the one I have.4

Mr: & Mrs: Breck, their daughter & Mrs: Wilson all desired me to present you their best respects— I was very pleasantly & agreeably entertained during my visit there, which was the first frolic I have had since I left town.

I have not yet perused the poem you sent as a present to Sarah— nor communicated the treasure to her— she will be gratified by this little token of your notice, more than by any reply I could have made to her effusions. It is a little singular, that the father of this family (Mr: Wistar) of German origin, is violently democratic in opposition to all the connection.5

Judge Rush it is, not the Dr: who is using all his influence in favor of Mr: Mc:Kean— I undertook to annalyse the characters of the Republican committee who write for the Chief, but Brown & Relf have not dared to publish & I cannot get the piece from them to send it elsewhere—6

I am in haste dear mother / Your Son

T B Adams.

RC (Adams Papers); internal address: “Mrs: A Adams.” Some loss of text where the seal was removed and due to wear at the edge.

1.

The Walpole, N.H., Farmer’s Weekly Museum, 19 Aug., disparaged the defense of Joseph Priestley by “A New-England Man,” writing that he “cannot be induced by the subtilty of polemic disputation, by the pomp of learning, by the pride of philosophy, by the pageanty of electric tricks, nor by all the convulsive spasms of the tortured mouse in his exhausted receiver, to respect the character of this ’busy and intermedling priest.’”

2.

The enclosure has not been found, but was likely an extract from JQA’s 9 July letter to TBA lamenting William Cobbett’s treatment of JA and providing an exhaustive update of Napoleon’s campaigns. He also enclosed letters from German acquaintances seeking assistance with U.S. legal matters and reported that he had sold TBA’s horse and shipped him a trunk (Adams Papers). The Massachusetts Mercury, 1 Oct., printed seven paragraphs of the letter that covered public matters, changing the date to 13 July and attributing it to “a gentleman of respectability in Europe.” A note printed below the extract from the “Communicator” disputed JQA’s assertion that Cobbett’s newspaper was 555 the most popular in the United States, claiming instead that “Porcupine’s Gazette is, and has been long despised by almost all Americans who love their country.TBA received JQA’s letter on 11 Sept. and answered it on the 23d, thanking his brother for the accounts of European politics, reporting on JQA’s financial affairs, and offering comment on Capt. Thomas Truxtun and the yellow fever in Philadelphia (Adams Papers).

3.

JQA signed the second Prussian-American Treaty of Amity and Commerce on 11 July in Berlin, for which see vol. 12:355, 356, replacing the original 1785 treaty, which expired on 8 Aug. 1796. Timothy Pickering enclosed a copy of the treaty in a letter to JA of 16 Sept. 1799 and reported that the original had arrived at his office (Adams Papers).

4.

The letters from Tilly Whitcomb to TBA have not been found.

5.

The prominent Democratic-Republican in the Wister family appears to have been Dr. Casper Wistar, a cousin of Daniel Wister. Dr. Wistar was vice president of the American Philosophical Society when Thomas Jefferson was named president of the organization in 1797. On 20 Aug. 1799 Wistar was mentioned as a potential Democratic-Republican candidate for Congress (John W. Jordan, ed., Colonial and Revolutionary Families of Pennsylvania, 3 vols., N.Y., 1911, 1:261–262; Jefferson, Papers , 29:276–277; Boston Gazette, 20 Aug.).

6.

The piece TBA sent to the Philadelphia Gazette has not been found but was possibly “To the Electors of Pennsylvania” by “Plain Truth,” which appeared in the newspaper on 4 October. The writer attacked “the ’republican’ committee” that supported Thomas McKean for governor, denied that Federalists were timing their attacks to influence the election, and criticized McKean’s support of Dr. George Logan and the protesters against the Alien Acts who were arrested at St. Mary’s Church in February.