Adams Papers Digital Edition

Papers of John Adams, volume 21

From John Hinckley Mitchell

From John Quincy Adams
John Adams to Jeremy Belknap, 22 October 1795 Adams, John Belknap, Jeremy
To Jeremy Belknap
Dear Sir Quincy October 22. 1795

Inclosed is the Letter of Dr Tucker.—1 If I should agree with him in his Maxim Fiat Justitia ruat Cælum2 the question would Still remain what is Justice. Justice to the Negroes would require that they should not be abandoned by their Masters and turned loose upon a World in which they have no Capacity to procure even a Subsistance. What would become of the old,? the young? the infirm? Justice to the World too would forbid that Such Numbers should be turn’d out to live by Violence or Theft or fraud.

I believe no better Expedient will be found than to prohibit the Importation of new Negroes, and Soften the Severity of the Condition of old ones, as much as possible, untill the increasing Population of the Country shall have multiplied the Whites to such a Superiority of Numbers, that the Blacks may be liberated by Degrees, with the Consent both of Master and Servant

your sincere

John Adams 419

RC (MHi:Jeremy Belknap Papers); internal address: “Dr Belknap”; endorsed: “V P. Adams Oct 22 / 1795.”

 1.

For St. George Tucker’s queries on slavery in colonial Massachusetts, see Belknap’s 2 March letter, and note 1, above.

 2.

Let justice be done, though the heavens should fall (John Bouvier, A Law Dictionary Adapted to the Constitution and Laws of the United States of America, 2 vols., Phila., 1868, 2:127).