Papers of John Adams, volume 18

To John Adams from C. W. F. Dumas, 12 October 1786 Dumas, C. W. F. Adams, John
From C. W. F. Dumas
Monsieur Lahaie 12e. Oct. 1786

Autant nous avons été en peine de Vous savoir avec Madame en mer par la tempête qu’il faisoit, autant nous a réjoui la nouvelle de votre arrivée à Londres,1 laquelle écrite ici par Mr. De Lynde, me fut com̃uniquée en son temps par Mr. Fagel, avec qui j’eus occasion de m’entretenir de V. E. à l’hôtel de France, & qui m’a chargé de vous faire parvenir ses complimens.

Mr. Jrujo,2 mon très cher ami, Chargé d’Affaires d’Espagne, que j’ai eu l’honneur de vous présenter chez Mr. le Ms. De Verac, part pour résider en la même qualité à la Cour Britanique. Avec le juste desir qu’il a de cultiver l’honneur de votre connoissance, un excès 481 de modestie lui fait penser qu’il a besoin pour cela d’une recom̃andation de ma part, qui est bien à son service, bien que je sache que sa patrie, son caractere, son mérite & ses qualités aimables, lui serviront auprès de V. E., com̃e par-tout ailleurs, d’introduction bien supréieure à la mienne.

Nous espérons de voir en ce pays, com̃e vous nous l’avez fait espérer, Made. Smith avec Mr. son Epoux, & de leur y rendre nos services agréables; & Madame Adams voudra bien recevoir avec eux les assurances de nos respects.

Je suppose que V. E. lit assidument la Gazette de Leide. Elle décrit si exactement, quoique succinctement la succession des évenemens dans ce pays, que cela me dispense d’entrer dans des détails là-dessus.3

Aujourd’hui est le grand jour du renouvellement de la Régence à Utrecht. J’ai tout lieu de m’assurer que tout se sera passé avec la décence & la fermeté dont vous avez été témoin à une occasion analogue.— Les Etats postiches d’Utrecht à Amersfort ont accepté la Médiation de L. N. & G. P. & des autres Confédérés, entre la Ville & eux.—4 Les Bachas de Gueldre, avec leur Sultan, s’embourbent de plus en plus. Après avoir menacé de tout envahir, ils n’osent sortir avec les troupes dont ils ont farci la Province, de peur que leurs Bourgeoisies ne leur cassent le cou.— En Frise une autre Oligarchie veut imiter celle de Gueldre; mais les Frisons n’endureront pas cela.— En Groningue, Overyssel & Zélande, ainsi qu’en Hollande, l’horreur contre la tyranne n’y fait que croître & embellir.— Et nos Diplomatiques ici depuis quelque temps sont muets com̃e des Disciples de Pythagore.5

Je suis avec grand respect / De Votre Exc1. le très humble & / trèsobéissant serviteur,

Cwf Dumas
TRANSLATION
Sir The Hague, 12 October 1786

As much as we were grieved to hear you were on the seas with madam in such a storm, we were just as delighted to hear the news of your arrival in London,1 which was marked here by Mr. Lynden, and was communicated to me in time by Mr. Fagel, with whom I had the opportunity to speak about your excellency at the Hôtel de France, and who requested that I relay his regards.

Mr. Irujo,2 my very dear friend, chargé d’affaires of Spain, whom I had 482 the honor of introducing to you at the Marquis de Verac’s, is departing to assume the same post at the British court. With the just desire that he has to foster the honor of your acquaintance, an excessive modesty causes him to believe that he needs a recommendation on my behalf, which is happily granted, though I know that his nation, his character, his merit, and his amiable qualities will serve as a far greater recommendation to your excellency, as to anyone else.

We hope to see in this country, as you have caused us to hope, Mrs. Smith with her husband, and to render them our gracious services; and would Mrs. Adams kindly accept, along with them, assurances of our respect.

I suppose that your excellency assiduously reads the Gazette de Leyde. It precisely, though succinctly, reports the succession of events in this country, which excuses me from having to enter into details.3

Today is the grand occasion of the renewal of the regency at Utrecht. I have every reason to believe that everything will transpire with the decency and firmness to which you were a witness on a similar occasion. The false states of Utrecht at Amersfort have accepted mediation between them and the city from Their High Mightinesses and other confederates.4 The pashas of Gelderland, along with their sultan, are becoming more and more mired in the mud. After having threatened to invade everything, they do not dare to mobilize the troops they have spread over the countryside for fear of getting their necks broken by their citizens. In Friesland another oligarchy wishes to imitate that of Gelderland, but the Frisians will not endure it. In Groningen, Overijssel, and Zeeland, as well as in Holland, a sense of repulsion against tyranny only grows greater and more beautiful. And our diplomats here have been, for some time, as silent as disciples of Pythagoras.5

I am with great respect your excellency’s most humble and most obedient servant

Cwf Dumas

RC (Adams Papers); internal address: “A Son Excellence Mr. Jn Adams, Esqr. M. P. des E. U.”

1.

For the storm that resulted in the Adamses spending four days at sea on their return from the Netherlands, see AFC , 7:331.

2.

This is Carlos Martínez de Irujo, Marquis of Casa Irujo, who would serve as Spanish minister to the United States between 1796 and 1808 ( Repertorium , 3:445).

3.

Here Dumas, at least to a degree, is contrasting the Gazette de Leyde’s treatment of events with that of other newspapers, such as the Gazette d’Amsterdam, which provided more expansive coverage.

4.

The new elected regency council for the city of Utrecht was initially sworn in on 28 Aug. 1786. Those who took the oath, however, filled out the remainder of the ousted council members’ terms. According to the city’s 1674 charter the council’s new one-year term began on 12 Oct., and the installation ceremony noted was reportedly carried out with unexampled pomp and solemnity. The situation was complicated by the fact that while the city of Utrecht was firmly in the Patriot camp, the provincial States of Utrecht, which also met in the city and was loyal to the stadholder, had relocated to Amersfoort, thirty miles away. For the moment, as Dumas indicates, the two parties accepted the mediation of the States of Holland and West Friesland, thus avoiding the immediate prospect 483 of armed conflict (Gazette d’Amsterdam, 13, 17 Oct. 1786).

5.

During the eight-year Pythagorean novitiate, aspiring disciples followed a strict ascetic lifestyle and took a vow of five years’ silence (Leonid Zhmud, Pythagoras and the Early Pythagoreans, transl. Kevin Windle and Rosh Ireland, Oxford, 2012, p. 163).

From John Adams to Thomas Bulfinch, 13 October 1786 Adams, John Bulfinch, Thomas
To Thomas Bulfinch
Sir. Grosvr. square Octr. 13. 1786

The Day before yesterday, I received the Letter you did me the honour to write me in January last—1 I had indeed long before received from Congress the Papers relative to similiar Claims in Boston with Instructions to use them when I should see a Prospect of success, if, upon any favourable turn in the Minds of this Court and Nation, any such prospect should ever occur—

I have not yet presented any of these Claims at Court, because there is not even a Possibility of their being regarded— You will see by Lord Carmarthen’s answer to my Memorial and Resignation requisition respecting the Frontier Posts, that nothing is to be expected while Laws are in force in any of the United States impeding the recovery of old british Debts— That your claim and many others in Boston are bonâ fide Debts I doubt not. But Law of the Land and not negotiation, is the remedy—and therefore, I frankly own I do not think, that the Dignity or the faith of the United States ought ever to have been compromised in these Matters—

I am

J A

LbC in WSS’s hand (Adams Papers); internal address: “Dr. Bulfinch—”; APM Reel 113.

1.

Dr. Thomas Bulfinch (1728–1802), Harvard 1746, inoculated AA and the Adams children during the Boston smallpox epidemic of 1775–1776, and was the father of federalist architect Charles Bulfinch (1763–1844), Harvard 1781, then on a grand tour of Europe ( AFC , 2:16; 6:162–163, 231; 7:369; ANB ). The elder Bulfinch’s letter of [Jan. 1786] (Adams Papers) was part of an effort by a contingent of Boston merchants to obtain restitution for goods seized by Gen. William Howe prior to the British Army’s evacuation in March 1776, for which see Samuel Austin’s 23 Dec. 1785 letter, and note 1, above.

Bulfinch alleged that on 24 Dec. 1775, his apothecary shop was “broke open, & all the Drugs, Mednes— &c carried of, without any account being taken of them, although I in person requested of the General that an Accot might be taken of them. It is true the Gen1. then told me that I need not be uneasy for my property, for that whatever was taken, was for the Use of His Majesty’s forces, and I should certainly be paid for them; and this he said in the presence and hearing of one of his Aid de Camps.” After the British officers seized his medicine and equipment, Bulfinch wrote, they left the shop doors open “all that Night & several Nights after, exposing the Goods to any and every person, who had a Mind to steal or destroy them” (Adams Papers). See also JA’s reply to Austin of 25 May 1786, and note 2, above, regarding a similarly fruitless petition.

484